U.S. CONGRESSMAN PAUL C. BROUN, M.D. 10th Congressional District of Georgia

image image image image image image
Blog // Blog
Dr. Broun's Health Care Bill
Posted by on October 21, 2009

A line-by-line summary of The OPTION Act

The OPTION Act (H.R. 3889)
The Offering Patients True and Individualized Options Now Act

1)  Make the Purchase of Health Care More Affordable to More People

  • Drastically expand the individual market available for individual purchasing
  • Increase pooling options
  • Lower the overarching cost of health care for everyone through the tax system

2)  Make All Health Care Related Expenses Totally Tax Deductible for Everyone

  • Extend the income tax deduction on health care premiums to all individuals
  • Allow for individuals to take tax deductions for health care related expenses they incur including all health care expenses currently allowed to be purchased with Health Savings Account (HSA) funds
  • Individuals who have employer health care plans but still incur costs on medical expenses, deductibles, premiums, pharmaceuticals (prescribed, over the counter, etc.), or any medical related expenses would qualify
  • Allow Medicare recipients to deduct their Medicare supplemental insurance premiums for tax purposes (typically AARP supplemental, but others qualify as well

3)  Significantly Expand Health Savings Accounts Contributions and Eligibility

  • Increase the maximum contribution level for tax deductible deposits into HSAs
  • Allow for Medicare recipients to continue to contribute money into their HSAs even after they reach Medicare eligibility (currently forbidden)
  • Allow any additional money in an HSA at the time of the account holder’s passing to be inherited by the beneficiaries of the account holder’s estate.
  • HSA contributions would continue to rollover year to year and be compounded.
  • Interest earned from HSA’s would be tax deferrable.
  • Companies would be allowed/encouraged to purchase catastrophic insurance for their employees as a companion for matching employee contributions (or a certain percentage of employee contributions) into an HSA
  • HSA savings would automatically be eligible to rollover into Medicare Savings Accounts (MSA) (discussed under point 4)
  • Individuals with HSAs would be allowed to donate their own personal HSA contributions to charity, which would also be a qualifying tax deduction

4)  Repeal and Reform the Barriers That Currently Exist for Physicians to Donate Charity and Pro Bono Care

  • Allow physicians a tax credit for providing charity medical care, with annual credits upwards of  $8,000
  • Repeal the barriers for physicians to volunteer at clinics.
  • Eligible charity care consists of both volunteering in clinics as well as pro bono work performed in a private practice

5)  Reform Medicare from being a Government Administered Health Care Program to a Market-Based Voucher System

  • Instead of Medicare being a government-run insurance provider, Medicare would instead issue vouchers to each participant in the program at the beginning of the year, at a specific amount equal to 110% of the current per beneficiary allotment of Medicare per county, for two purposes:
    • 1) Used to buy private insurance 
      2) Contribution of additional funds into an MSA (which would compound   and rollover year to year and become part of estate on passing).  MSA would have the same tax benefits and be under the same regulations as HSAs

6)  Allow for Individuals to Keep their Health Insurance Indefinitely if they Choose once they Leave their Jobs

  • Expands the portability of health insurance plans for individuals

7)  Encourages Better Transparency in Health Care Pricing

  • Nothing in this legislation will preclude a medical provider or an insurance company from publicly disclosing their prices, which will allow for greater transparency in the health care market.

8)  Review and Reform Current EMTALA Regulations

  • Allows a medical professional with certified, basic medical knowledge (such as a  PA, RN, EMT, etc.) to triage patients coming into an Emergency Department  (ED) and decide if their ailment is truly “emergent”, by the current EMC standard:
           
    • If a treatment is deemed to not be emergent then a technician, with redundant approval, would be able to direct the patient to a more suitable treatment place, such as a clinic, an urgent care facility or simply to their regular physician.  Ideally, this component would be part of a large scale education and resource allocation program, to help serve underserved populations by utilizing the hospitals, clinics and doctors in various areas.

9)  Eliminates the Barriers to Shop Across State Lines for Health Insurance

  • Using the Constitutional Authority vested in the Commerce Clause, individuals  would be allowed to shop across state lines for individual health insurance.

10)  Expand Pooling Options to Allow Any Qualified Entity to Create an Insurance Pool and Negotiate Health Insurance Plans on Behalf of any Participating Member

  • This provision takes existing Association Health Plan Language (as of yet not  law) and expands it to allow for the inclusion of not just associations, but any  entity (Rotary Clubs, Neighborhood Associations, etc.) who meet basic  qualifications such as having a Constitution, conducting regular meetings and  having a tax identification number on file with a state’s Secretary of State’s  office, to negotiate on behalf of their participating membership health care plans  and rates.

 

Comments
The opinions expressed below are those of their respective authors and do not necessarily represent those of this office.
  • Lois Thurston commented on 10/22/2009
    Great plan! So far, this is the first plan that make any sense at all. However, I didn't notice what kind of health care would be available for indigent people (on disability, Medicaid, etc.). Would there be cuts in their services or would your bill reach out to them...the most vulnerable? Perhaps it is somewhere in the Medicare section that I might have missed....anyway, please make sure something is there about this segment of our population. Also, what about catastrophic illnesses?
  • Herb Yeomans commented on 10/24/2009
    Thank you for trying to do the right thing.
  • Shelby Good commented on 10/24/2009
    People who live on Social Security cannot afford private insurance. We have paid all our lives to have SS and Medicare when we got older. Our government has used OUR money for other things and now SS & Medicare are basically broke. If our elected officials had set this money aside into an account for this purpose only, and drew the interest off it over the years, SS would have plenty of money. Also, how much of OUR money has been used for people who never paid a cent into SS?This is just like having a bank account and someone stealing all your money from it. I have voted for you ever since you got into politics, but now I am questioning if I did the right thing or not. I'm beginning to think all politicians do not have any real interest in their constituents--just what's in it for themselves. If you politicians had the same Medicare coverage that we do, then you would understand. Why don't you and your colleagues put yourselves on the same type of medical care that you expect us to live with? If it would be good enough for you--then it would be good enough for everyone. The current Medicare program has proved to be a good one. I've had many incidents where I've had to use it, and it has always been adequate. It may not be the best but it's the best we've got, so just leave it alone and leave us old folks alone. Needless to say, I'm disappointed that you want to privatize Medicare.
  • First Name Last Name commented on 10/24/2009
    Please don't do this.
  • Chris Carroll commented on 10/24/2009
    Please don't do this. Please.
  • Judy Selzer commented on 10/24/2009
    This looks like real reform. After moving to Georgia five years ago from Virginia, we know what it is like to have to give up a very good policy at a lower cost, to buy insurance in Georgia. We had a grace period of two years and hung on to that policy for the complete two years. We had low deductible and much, much lower premiumn payments (we own our own business). But now have $2,000 a year in deductibles and at least three times the amount in premiumns. Now go figure, if we could shop across state lines, you know that we would love to do that. The Federal goverment regulated us out of good coverage at a fair rate and that just plain stinks. Thanks for making across state lines buying of insurance policies, one of your major reforms. Sincerely, Judy Selzer
  • Charles Fleishel commented on 10/24/2009
    What about Tort Reform?
  • Charles Coone commented on 10/24/2009
    This makes more sense than anything I have seen proposed yet. Please PUSH this bill!
  • Ginger Purkey commented on 10/24/2009
    Dear Paul, I like your idea. How can we help YOU get this into the bill? or at least try and get the opposition to listen. Why are the people in Washington trying to hurt the American people?? I don't understand why we can't get along and do what is best for the country and not one political party???? Thank you for all your hard work!
  • chris livingstone commented on 10/24/2009
    Please keep trying to get a reasonable health care bill passed. We are dependent on you and others to protect our coverage. Thank you and keep working for the American people.
  • HERMAN WATSON commented on 10/24/2009
    Rep. Broun: I watched you and some more Doctors on Cspan discuss Obama Care. What I heard about The Demo's plan, the more I feel that they are trying to Socialize this country. I believe that all of the 40 plans the Republicans have are much better than any part of Obama Care. As an aged retired citizen, I am scared that my wife and I will suffer badly and lose everything that we have. I retired from the military after 20 years of service primarily because of the lack of promised health care. I retired from federal government after 33 years(Social Security Admin). That is a total of 53 Years of federal service. I served and fough in Korea and Vietnam. Between Medicare, federal insurance and military Tricare for Life, I receive fairly decent health care. I have supported you from day one and will continue to do so. I what ever you can do, you will do it. Thank you!
  • Allen Brock commented on 10/25/2009
    1) Make the purchase of health care insurance more affordable to more people; The insurance companies already control too much of our health care. If they are going to stay in business then they need more regulation,, not more income. 2) Make all health care related expenses tax deductible for all individuals; Agree, so why hasn't it been done already, and why aren't the states already doing it? 3) Significantly expand health savings accounts contributions and eligibility; Not a good idea, since not all have the means to contribute to an HCSA. 4) Repeal and reform the barriers that currently exist for physicians to donate charity and pro bono care; Is this a federal problem to a state problem? 5) Reform Medicare from being a government administered health care program to a market-based voucher system;Why, so the insurance companies can get more money? 6) Allow for individuals to keep their health insurance if they choose once they leave their jobs; Why not do away with employer-provided insurance and end this problem? 7) Expand pooling options to allow any qualified entity to create an insurance plan for members; Again, this just gives the insurance more money. 8) Enable individuals to shop across state lines for health insurance; As I understand it, this is a state problem and not dictated by the federal government. 9) Allow transparency into health care pricing; and Eye-wassh 10) Review and reform current EMTALA regulations. I thought this was already policy.
  • Geneva Lankford-Blanks commented on 10/26/2009
    #5 is just crazy! And what happens to the people that do not have health care and do not have children to qualify for assistance? Everything is about people who have insurance - it ssems this is still keeping the insurance companies in control.
  • Wanda Perry commented on 10/26/2009
    I think that this would benefit most Americans. There should be a way that we could vote on issues such as this and not have to depend on the government to decide for us. What ever happend to "for the people, by the people" The president's plan is only helping the illegals and the really poor and will end up costing the middle class, tax paying majority to have to pay more in taxes. Please help!
  • Theresa McTier commented on 10/26/2009
    This sounds like a viable option to me.
  • Norman Baker commented on 10/26/2009
    Just sign me and my family up! I do not want the federal government in my business no more than what they are now. The people are just about on the verge of an uprising with Obama's plans of changing this Great Nation. We do not want to live in a country like Kena, and he can damn well go back.
  • Andy Warner commented on 10/26/2009
    Dr. Broun, I wholeheartedly support your OPTION Act! May God bless you for your hard work in representing us. Andy Warner Lincolnton, GA
  • alfredo pagatpatan commented on 10/27/2009
    I support this legislation...how can we get the word on this out so that it gets more notice and wider support?
  • Troy Harris commented on 10/27/2009
    Bravo! I would only add two suggestions. Provide vouchers for a system for those who qualify as being below a yet to be determined poverty line such that they would be able to shop for a high deductible type coverage plan and assist in providing for and helping them manage the MSA portion so as to incentivize them to be prudent health care shoppers/consumers. At least some form of limited tort reform, such that all cases must be screened by a medico-judicial review board to determine if there is validity to malpractice claim. Keep up the great work! Troy D. Harris, MD, FACEP
  • David Bruyninckx commented on 10/27/2009
    Please support and sign the bill HR615. I am dissappointed that it does not really force congressmen to have to take the government option insurance, but only urges. That is your out and only makes it look like the senators that sign the bill will follow through with giving up your fabulous medical benefits.
  • james farmer commented on 10/27/2009
    Your plan would be great for me,not for the many who are unemployed and don't have any money,also my wife is going to be on social security in december your plan would not fit her because she won't have much money and as it stands right now we both don't have insurance so we have 2 go to the ER inorder 2 get our prescripion I won't have insurance till december and my dad is on a fixed income many can't aford helth care,even I can't @ this time because its to costly and I'm a owner operator of my own trucking company and with times like they are I can't aford much Obama is puting heavy regulations on us and with his helth care plan he will make things worse he wants to take down our country and impose marxism,well with me ill take the fine and ill not pay that because ill not have a dam marxist telling me what to do and how to live my life and how to run my business he is going to start a revolt posibly a WAR more and more people are starting to talk about a real revolt and not just a protest I myself don't know what to think or do I'm just trying to make a livingt
  • Richard Fessel commented on 10/27/2009
    I apreciate your work in putting this together. Is anybody in Congress listening to you? What do you think of TORT reform? I believe that should be part of any healthcare reform bill. Thanks, Richard Fessel Charles City, IA
  • brian wade commented on 11/4/2009
    Charity Care means the hours that a physician provides medical care (as defined in section 213(d)(1)(A)) on a volunteer or pro bono basis. I would really like to know that is going to work.. There is a saying you get what you pay for and that term scares me. COBRA CONTINUATION COVERAGE EXTENDED-sounds great but I still cant afford cobra but thanks.. REPLACEMENT OF MEDICARE PART A ENTITLEMENT WITH MEDICARE REFORM VOUCHER PROGRAM-The Secretary shall establish a program to be known as the Medicare Reform Voucher Program.. ection 226 of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 426) is amended by adding at the end the following new subsections.. Is not SSI already over strained, though this bill is shifting cost over to SSI.. And your interstate commerce of insurance, the states will have to petition the insurance companies to come into there state.. What, correct me if I am wrong but the states have already had that power. Please come up with something better please!!!
  • Martin Meaders commented on 11/30/2009
    Number 5 only if seniors can actually get decent coverage. You actually did this on one page so what is in the 1997 and 2074 page versions except tyranny. I would think you would have jumped all over tort reform being a physician but I failed to spot it. One big problem is getting this out to the public.
  • WIlliam Pierson commented on 1/30/2010
    What I don't appreciate are Socialist Insurance Monopolies that spend almost all of our health dollars on bureaucracy and CEO bonuses and make our small and large companies less competitive in the world due to high health costs. No wonder our jobs are being sent out of the country. We need an Federal Option, just like all the other countries that have higher standards of living (and life expectancy) than we do such as Germany, England, Australia, New Zealand, Switerland, France, Belgium, Japan, Denmark, Sweden.... Please write down feel free to complete the list. Thank you for your attention.
Post a Comment
Fill out the fields below to submit a comment